Subscribe: RSS
Episode: Why Orthodontic Practices Stall at $2 Million, With Amanda Floyd Show: GrowOrtho Host: Luke Infinger, CEO and co-founder of HIP Creative Guest: Amanda Floyd, founder of Amanda Floyd Consulting; former office manager at Fishbein Orthodontics and former regional vice president for Smile Doctors in Florida Published: November 17, 2026 Last updated: November 17, 2026 Runtime: 63 minutes
Summary: Orthodontic practices that stall between $2 million and $3 million in annual production usually have a treatment coordinator (TC) problem before they have a marketing problem. Amanda Floyd, who helped grow Fishbein Orthodontics from about $800,000 in production in 2012 to roughly $20 million by 2020, says the first fix is a simpler consult with less explaining and less doctor time in the room, run the same way 95 to 97 percent of the time. In about 75 percent of the practices she coaches, the right TC is already on staff and needs more training. Luke Infinger adds that $750 off and $1,000 off are the two best-performing social media offers across HIP Creative’s partner practices, and that doctors who refuse promotions or underfund marketing are usually held back by their own assumptions about what will work in their market.
Topics: treatment coordinator process, case acceptance, consult close rate, orthodontic marketing budgets, discount promotions, delegation, AI for practice teams
Entities named: Amanda Floyd Consulting, Fishbein Orthodontics, Dr. Ben Fishbein, Fishbein Fundamentals, Smile Doctors, HIP Creative, NotebookLM, ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Slack, Higgsfield, Runway
About the author
Luke Infinger | CEO and co-founder, HIP Creative Luke Infinger leads HIP Creative, a growth partner for orthodontic, dental, and specialty practices, and has run paid social and patient acquisition for orthodontic practices since 2016. He hosts GrowOrtho, where he interviews the doctors and operators behind high-growth practices.
Most conversations about orthodontic practice growth start with marketing. Amanda Floyd starts with the consult room. Floyd spent more than a decade helping Dr. Ben Fishbein turn a seven-person, $800,000-a-year office in Pensacola, Florida, into a multi-location practice she now describes as a $30 million brand. When a practice stalls at $2 million to $3 million, her first move is almost always the treatment coordinator process.
Her advice for the stuck doctor is specific. Simplify the consult so patients can say yes the same day. Get the doctor out of the room sooner. Train the TC you already have, because three out of four times that person is capable. Then stop doing work you could pay someone else to do, including editing your own schedule templates.
Luke Infinger, CEO of HIP Creative, covers the marketing side: what HIP’s packages cost, which promotional offers convert best on Facebook and Instagram, and why “that would never work in our practice” may be the most expensive sentence in orthodontics. The conversation opens with a frank look at where AI helps a practice team and where it falls short.
Key takeaways
- When a practice stalls at $2 million to $3 million in production, Amanda Floyd’s first change is the treatment coordinator (TC) consult process, start to finish.
- Overexplained consults lose starts. Floyd’s standard, simple consult works 95 to 97 percent of the time, and the TC adapts for the other 2 to 3 percent.
- In roughly 75 percent of the practices Floyd’s team coaches, the TC already in the role is capable and needs more training.
- Many practices can’t say what their consult close rate is, which means nobody is managing it.
- Across HIP Creative’s partner practices, $750 off and $1,000 off are the two best-performing social media offers, and they perform about the same.
- HIP’s marketing packages run $2,000 to $7,000 a month before ad spend, while a full orthodontic treatment typically costs patients $6,000 to $8,000.
- Doctors who handle HR, marketing, and schedule templates themselves cap their own growth. Dr. Ben Fishbein’s rule is that the best thing an orthodontist can do for the practice is be an orthodontist.
How did Fishbein Orthodontics grow from $800,000 to a $30 million practice?
Amanda Floyd joined a small Pensacola orthodontic office in 2012. It had seven employees, about $800,000 in annual production, and no office manager. The owner did his own hiring, wrote his own staff meeting notes, and approved every lunch-and-learn. When he became ill and sold quickly to Dr. Ben Fishbein, who was in his early 30s and about a year out of residency, Floyd was working as the full-time treatment coordinator and clinical coordinator and was asking to go part-time.
Fishbein asked her to become office manager instead. He told her up front that he had no budget for a raise, and he sketched a plan on a legal pad: if they grew the practice, he would share the upside. She still has the notes.
By Floyd’s account, the growth went like this. The practice reached about $4 million in 2016, the year HIP Creative began running its marketing (March) and the year it opened its Pace, Florida, office (September). It jumped to about $11 million in 2017 after opening two offices and hiring several standout team members. In 2018 it produced $15 million to $15.5 million, launched Fishbein Fundamentals as a training event for other practices, and opened two more offices in the same week that December. It finished 2020 at around $20 million.
COVID tested that team. Fishbein Orthodontics had about 80 employees and was closed for roughly seven weeks. Because Florida unemployment benefits were hard to get, leadership cut spending, mostly from the marketing budget, and paid the whole team through the shutdown. Floyd says that decision let the practice reopen quickly, because it didn’t have to rehire or wait to see who would come back.
Floyd credits the growth to two traits she shares with Fishbein: openness to new ideas and the follow-through to act on them. Later, as a regional vice president for Smile Doctors overseeing Florida practices for five years, she learned how different growth looks when the doctor and team don’t share that mindset.
What should an orthodontic practice change first when it’s stuck at $2 million to $3 million?
Amanda Floyd’s first change in a stalled orthodontic practice is the treatment coordinator (TC) process, rebuilt start to finish. The TC is the team member who runs the new-patient consult and presents treatment and fees. Most practices Floyd’s firm works with sit in the $2 million to $3 million range, and the consult is where she finds the biggest leaks.
Her second change is making sure the person in the TC seat is strong. About 75 percent of the time, a good TC is already in the role and needs more training. In the rest, the practice needs to move someone into the seat or hire. Floyd calls this “right people, right seat.”
Two problems come up repeatedly. First, the practice’s best TC often isn’t consulting full-time because she is also managing the office or working chairside, while someone with a low close rate handles the consults. Second, nobody knows the close rate. Floyd says she regularly walks into practices where the team can’t tell her what percentage of consults start treatment, because no one tracks it.
After the TC process, Floyd looks at marketing systems and the phones. Her point is that every link has to work together: a strong TC can’t close patients who never book, and strong marketing is wasted if the person answering the phone can’t get callers in the door.
Why does a simpler orthodontic consult close more patients?
Amanda Floyd says most struggling treatment coordinators (TCs) overexplain. The consult is clunky or overdone, every detail gets covered, and the doctor spends far too long in the room. Patients today want simplicity, and Floyd says complexity gives them a reason to go home and keep researching when they would otherwise have started treatment that day.
Luke Infinger points to an old sales principle: the confused mind doesn’t buy. Patients have usually researched orthodontics before they arrive, and many now ask AI chat tools their questions first. They don’t need a lesson on how every tooth moves.
TCs often worry about the patient who has more questions or the detail they didn’t disclose. Floyd’s answer is that the patient will be in the office every eight weeks or so during treatment, so questions can be answered when they come up and are relevant. Her teams run the same simple consult 95 to 97 percent of the time and adapt in the moment for the 2 to 3 percent of patients who need something different.
Why is “that would never work in our practice” so costly?
When Luke Infinger researched this episode, one question kept surfacing: what is the most expensive thing an orthodontist says? The answer was “that would never work in our practice.” The same doctor who wants to grow rejects the roadmap that would get them there. Infinger sees it when attendees at Fishbein Fundamentals pick apart the Fishbein model instead of asking how it could be adapted.
Amanda Floyd’s response is that nobody has to build a $30 million practice, but most could build a $3 million one. The harder problem is doctors who name a goal and then won’t invest in the people needed to reach it, or who nickel-and-dime employees and patients.
Floyd gave an example from the day before the recording. A doctor she coaches was upset because a patient had emailed to complain about her treatment results. Floyd’s view is that Dr. Ben Fishbein would refund that patient every time, because fighting a patient’s perception rarely changes it and often costs a negative review, a negative social media post, and hours of staff time. Fishbein’s line for this is “you can be right or you can be rich.” Floyd adds that the saying applies to energy as much as money.
Infinger notes that his easiest and fastest-growing partners share a trait: they are analytical but approach growth from a positive frame. They focus on what’s possible, and they don’t agonize over the performance of every individual ad.
Which tasks should an orthodontist stop doing to grow the practice?
Luke Infinger says he often catches orthodontists doing $20-an-hour work. Amanda Floyd lists the usual culprits: HR, marketing, small scheduling decisions, and editing the practice’s own schedule templates, which she finds surprisingly common.
When a doctor says a task has to be done right so they have to do it, Floyd’s answer is direct: either the right people aren’t on the team, or the practice hasn’t invested in coaching and training them. Infinger’s questions for that doctor are practical. Have you talked to the team member about it? Have you let them watch you do it? Do you have a recorded standard operating procedure (SOP)? And if the person truly can’t do the job, why are they still in that role?
Some doctors love the business side, and Floyd says that’s fine. A doctor who wants to run a small, profitable office can do that. Doctors who enjoy the business and still grow fast tend to stay involved at a high level while a strong management team runs the day-to-day.
The principle underneath is to do what only you can do. A TC can’t move teeth, and neither can the scheduling coordinator or HR. Dr. Ben Fishbein puts it simply: the best thing an orthodontist can do for the practice is be an orthodontist, putting braces on and taking braces off.
Is $2,000 a month enough to grow an orthodontic practice?
Luke Infinger says orthodontic practices routinely underspend on growth. HIP Creative’s full fee is about $7,000 a month, with packages starting at $2,000 a month, both before ad spend, and the agency still hears that it’s expensive. Infinger’s counterpoint is that the same practices ask patients to pay $6,000 to $8,000 for full treatment. Expecting to add $500,000 to $1 million in annual production while spending $2,000 a month on marketing doesn’t add up.
Amanda Floyd hears the same objection about her consulting fees. Dr. Ben Fishbein’s view has always been that you have to spend money to make money. Floyd says her firm will turn down a practice that wants a lower fee rather than compromise on what it delivers, and she points out that many of her consulting clients also work with HIP.
Infinger compares it to cars: there’s nothing wrong with a Toyota or a Kia, but there is an obvious difference between those and an Audi or a Porsche, and buyers know what they’re paying for.
Do discount promotions cheapen an orthodontic brand?
Luke Infinger explains why promotions matter on social media. On Google, patients are already searching for an orthodontist. On Facebook and Instagram, nobody is looking for you, so an ad has to interrupt them, and price-based offers (“$500 off,” “as low as,” “starting at”) do that well. After running thousands of offers across HIP Creative’s partner practices, Infinger says the two best performers are $750 off and $1,000 off, and they perform nearly the same.
Many doctors still say they aren’t a discount practice. Infinger’s reply is that several of HIP’s partners running these offers charge some of the highest fees in their markets. The real question, he says, is whether you want the patient to come to you or to a general dentist or another orthodontist down the road.
Amanda Floyd says Fishbein Orthodontics runs a $750 offer every Black Friday, as do most of her clients. Her view is that a brand lives in the patient experience: a bright, comfortable office, good lighting and music, and a team that’s glad to see you. A one-time offer doesn’t cheapen that. Infinger adds that the doctors most worried about cheapening their brand often have dated offices, including one he describes as a windowless third-floor suite.
Floyd also points to her own shopping habits. She shows up for a local boutique’s 20 percent friends-and-family sale, shops luxury outlets, and recently bought from a favorite clothing brand to get a free scarf with purchase. None of it made her think less of those brands.
Can AI save an orthodontic practice time and money?
Amanda Floyd’s team has scaled back its everyday use of AI. She believes the process of learning is where people build skill, and skipping it with AI means team members aren’t learning. She still uses ChatGPT as a voice-driven thinking partner and for planning.
Luke Infinger sees two problems with AI in practice teams. The first is that most people don’t check AI output before they hit send. At HIP Creative, 35 team members use an internal AI tool inside Slack that is trained on how HIP operates, with two team members assigned to review its quality and add rules when it gets something wrong. The second problem is expertise: if a prospect reads a strong AI-written message and wants a deeper call, can the sender explain the material?
Infinger also notes that the efficiency gains many businesses expected haven’t shown up yet in his experience. Token costs add up, and AI tends to generate more ideas and more work rather than less. Floyd agrees: AI can help team members with specific tasks and workflows, but practices still need well-trained people.
One practical use Infinger recommends is Google’s NotebookLM for onboarding. A practice can load its training material and generate podcast-style audio overviews, explainer videos, slide decks, infographics, quizzes, and flashcards, which makes it easier to check whether a new team member is retaining what they learned.
How can an orthodontist grow without hiring a consultant or agency?
Amanda Floyd’s advice for a doctor going it alone is to find at least one or two likable, capable self-starters who will do the hands-on work of growth. Fishbein Orthodontics grew before it invested heavily in marketing because a handful of people bought into the vision, and several of them still work with Floyd today.
If the doctor can’t grow and can’t keep good people, Floyd says the work starts with the doctor. She recommends podcasts and books on personal development to address the limiting beliefs that hold a practice back. Luke Infinger compares it to the airplane oxygen mask: put yours on first, then help your team.
Floyd ties this to routine. On days she completes her full morning (Bible study and devotional, a workout, journaling, an audiobook, and progress toward 10,000 steps), the rest of the day runs smoothly. On days she skips it, she’s behind by mid-afternoon. Infinger’s version is to keep doing the foundational habits that got you results, even after they start to feel unnecessary.
Frequently asked questions
Why do orthodontic practices get stuck at $2 million to $3 million?
According to Amanda Floyd, the most common cause is the treatment coordinator (TC) process. Consults are overexplained, the doctor spends too long in the room, and no one tracks the close rate. Doctors who keep doing administrative work such as HR and schedule templates also limit how much the practice can grow.
Should a stalled practice replace its treatment coordinator?
Usually not. Floyd says that in about 75 percent of practices, the TC already in the role is capable and needs more training. In the remaining cases, the practice needs to move a stronger team member into the seat or hire one.
What discount offer works best in orthodontic Facebook and Instagram ads?
Across thousands of offers run for HIP Creative’s partner practices, Luke Infinger says $750 off and $1,000 off perform best, and they perform about the same. Fishbein Orthodontics runs a $750 offer every Black Friday.
How much does HIP Creative charge for orthodontic marketing?
Luke Infinger says HIP’s packages range from $2,000 a month to a full fee of about $7,000 a month, both before ad spend. He compares that to typical full-treatment fees of $6,000 to $8,000 per patient.
How should an orthodontist handle a patient who is unhappy with their results?
Amanda Floyd says Dr. Ben Fishbein would refund the patient and move on. Arguing rarely changes a patient’s perception and risks negative reviews, negative social media posts, and lost staff time. Fishbein sums it up as “you can be right or you can be rich.”
Can AI replace orthodontic team members?
Neither guest thinks so yet. Floyd says AI helps with specific tasks but practices still need educated people, and Infinger says AI output has to be checked and coached by someone who understands the material.
Glossary
Treatment coordinator (TC): The team member who runs the new-patient consult, presents the treatment plan and fees, and asks the patient to start. Close rate: The percentage of new-patient consults that start treatment. Production: The total value of treatment a practice delivers in a period, the standard revenue measure for orthodontic practices. Start: A patient who commits to and begins treatment. DSO / OSO: Dental service organization or orthodontic service organization, a company that owns or supports multiple practices and handles business operations. Smile Doctors is an OSO. SOP: Standard operating procedure, a documented or recorded way to do a recurring task. Schedule template: The pre-built daily structure that tells the front desk which appointment types go in which slots.
Full episode transcript
Lightly edited for readability. Filler words, false starts, and crosstalk have been removed.
[00:00] AI inside a practice team
Luke Infinger: So what do you think about all this AI stuff? I’m curious about your opinion on AI.
Amanda Floyd: My opinion on AI has changed so much over the past year. We were so excited about it when we first started getting going on Claude Cowork, and I know I talked to you about it multiple times. It’s gone so far that way that we’ve scaled our team back from using it in everyday things, because I feel like the journey to learning is so much of the process. When you’re skipping that, I don’t think people are truly learning. Our approach has always been very personal, and I don’t want to lose that.
Luke Infinger: That’s the big challenge for me. If you’re using AI, are you actually checking it before you hit send? Most people aren’t. I’ll tell you who is one of the best: Kyle. Kyle is a good writer. His reading comprehension is great; he can read something so fast, clearly understand it, and articulate it. So he really checks and also coaches his AI. If you’re not reading it, checking it, and saying “hey, how’d you get this wrong?”, putting some rules in place, building a skill, that’s tough. We’re doing an AI call after this. We have 35 team members using a specific tool inside of Slack that’s coached on how we run, and Justin and Noah are kind of the police of it, and we love it. But AI slop is one thing. The other thing I think you’re mentioning is, are you actually an expert? If you send something to someone and it has really good points and they say, “Let’s get on a call and go deeper,” could you actually break down that information?
Amanda Floyd: Can you explain it? Right.
Luke Infinger: And there are just so many tools. When you and I talked a year ago, I mentioned using Gemini. Claude kind of led the race for a while, then GPT Astra came out, which is really good. Now I’m using GrokBot a ton, which is interesting. I’m playing around with building an organization, so I have a chief of staff and then bots that are team members underneath that. But you’re right, there’s only so good AI can be. Then you have to know, and Zach knows a lot of this, what you’re going to connect it to. If I’m going to make really good video, I have to connect it to Higgsfield and Runway. And now all these studies are coming out, and you’ve probably seen this, where it’s not saving companies money because they’re burning token usage, and it’s not saving them time because they’re coming up with more work and more ideas from AI. All this belief about what it was going to do inside a business, drive efficiency, drive down headcount, hasn’t actually happened.
Amanda Floyd: It has not come to fruition yet. We still use it regularly, right? I’ve gone from Gemini to ChatGPT to Claude and back to ChatGPT. I’m back to ChatGPT now; it’s my favorite. I use it almost like a thought partner where I just speak into it. And my favorite use is vacation planning, or any planning like that, because it’s so quick.
Luke Infinger: Now with Dot, I don’t know if you’ve messed around with Dot, it has a vault for passwords and credit cards. So if it gave you a trip plan and it has access to your Bonvoy and Delta accounts, it could just go book it.
Amanda Floyd: Oh, that’s so cool.
Luke Infinger: You should play around with Dot inside of GPT. But I also think there’s so much hype. We’re obviously talking to orthodontists on this podcast, and there’s a lot of hype about how it can help an orthodontist inside a practice. I don’t know that all the hype is real.
Amanda Floyd: I think it can help team members with certain tasks, but I don’t know that it saves time and money long-term. Maybe you get better ideas, you can get some workflows, you can build some things around it, but we still need people, and the people need to be educated. What we’re trying to do is use it in a way where you can educate yourself further, but it’s not the end.
Luke Infinger: It’ll be interesting to see where it goes. Some of the stuff we’re doing with AI, I couldn’t have imagined six months ago that we’d be here. So six months from now, twelve months from now, where are we going to be? What can it do? It is super cool, but it is a tool. For the first time, I actually went and did research on you.
Amanda Floyd: Oh, really?
Luke Infinger: Yeah, because we’re talking about AI. I got Grok to do research, and then I gave the research it did to NotebookLM. Have you ever used that?
Amanda Floyd: No.
Luke Infinger: It’s pretty cool. It can create a podcast on the information, so it made its own podcast of the questions Grok came up with. It can do a slide deck, an explainer video, an infographic. It’s built more for learning. It can also build quizzes and flashcards.
Amanda Floyd: So this is the pearl I’m leaving with today.
Luke Infinger: Even for your stack and IP, if you’re bringing on a new team member and you want to make sure they’re retaining the info, you could build quizzes and flashcards that are actually fun, with explainer videos of your content.
Amanda Floyd: Okay, I love this. What did the research tell you?
[06:09] From Arkansas to Pensacola
Luke Infinger: It went all the way back to you in Arkansas. I knew you were from Arkansas, but I don’t know a lot about that time of your life. I was hoping we could start there. What was life like before you came to Florida?
Amanda Floyd: Arkansas is where I was born and raised. I had Casey; I was a single mom. I started working at a pediatric office.
Luke Infinger: What did you do before you got into ortho and pediatric dentistry?
Amanda Floyd: I worked for a general practice for about nine months. I knew that wasn’t for me, but I loved it. I loved the doctor. It was a great practice, him and his wife, two hygienists, and me.
Luke Infinger: So you went to work right out of high school?
Amanda Floyd: No, I had Casey. When she was almost two, I went to dental assisting school. I thought I wanted to be a dental hygienist, so I figured I’d start somewhere. I went to dental assisting school and got the job at the general office when Casey was around two. When she was almost three, I left the general office and went into a pediatric dental office. I worked for two different pediatric dentists, and they both did ortho, so I learned pediatric ortho. I worked at that one practice for almost ten years and loved it. I did ortho, I did pedo, and I was the clinical manager there. Then we moved to Florida.
Luke Infinger: What was the deciding factor to come to Florida?
Amanda Floyd: Chris’s dad passed away when he was young. He was only 70.
Luke Infinger: So you met Chris in Arkansas and got married.
Amanda Floyd: Yes. Shortly after we got married, his dad died. He was only 70, and his parents had just retired, so it was a shock to Chris and to the family. Seventy feels so young. His parents were from here, and interestingly enough, my parents are from here too, from Pensacola. My dad went to school in Pensacola and my mom went to school in Milton. My whole family besides aunts and uncles lived in Arkansas, and we met and got married in Arkansas, but both of our families were from here. After his dad died, his brother still lived here and Chris really wanted to be close to his brother. So we moved here first, and then all of our family slowly trickled down. Within about four years, all of our families lived here.
[08:39] Beaches, mountains, and fishing trips
Luke Infinger: Are you a beach person?
Amanda Floyd: Not really. We bought a boat about a year and a half ago, and I’ve been on it twice. That was Chris’s birthday present. I can enjoy a casual boat ride to go to lunch, but I’m more of a mountain person. I loved growing up in Arkansas. I did rappelling, mountain biking, hiking, all sorts of fun things.
Luke Infinger: I’m not the biggest beach person, and I didn’t love it growing up, but it’s grown on me. The way I feel when I’m on the beach makes me feel so much better.
Amanda Floyd: There’s definitely something reenergizing to your spirit about being at the beach. I feel the same way in the mountains with a stream going through. There’s just something about nature in general.
Luke Infinger: We talked about this before filming: biohacking and health. It can get kind of woo-woo, but connecting with the earth, grounding, getting your feet in the sand, sunlight, it helps me a ton. My father-in-law has a boat and is big into fishing, like red snapper.
Amanda Floyd: Oh yeah, that’s Chris.
Luke Infinger: That’s so much different than just going to the beach. Going out to the pass, maybe Fort McRee, can be enjoyable sometimes.
Amanda Floyd: As long as it’s not deep-sea fishing, I’m good with it. If it’s deep sea, I can definitely get sick. I’d rather be at home. I don’t want to be out on the boat for nine hours. Chris will do overnight trips. I can’t say how much I would hate that.
Luke Infinger: I actually like inshore fishing. We do a staycation and fish from the beach and catch pompano and whiting, and we were catching massive redfish last time. That can be more fun than going 60 miles out. My father-in-law’s idea was to go out at night, sleep for an hour or two, wake up at 5:00 or 6:00 AM, and start fishing. I went one time, and it was a no-go for me.
Amanda Floyd: Not my thing. Maybe Chris needs to talk to your father-in-law.
Luke Infinger: They would 100 percent be buddies. Hunting camps, fishing trips.
Amanda Floyd: The hunting leases all over. I don’t even know where all we have leases.
Luke Infinger: It’s always been weird to me, getting so excited over killing a deer. I’ve shot several deer, and deer meat can be okay depending on how you cook it. But I’ve never been fist-bumping and yelling. Honestly, a fun hunt is a bird shoot, because you’re constantly shooting and moving.
Amanda Floyd: Sitting in a deer blind for hours upon hours? No.
[11:59] One thing no one knows about Amanda
Luke Infinger: You’ve done a ton of podcasts. What is one thing that maybe no one knows about you? Something interesting, funny, quirky.
Amanda Floyd: I feel like I speak so much in my stories that people know everything I’ll say.
Luke Infinger: Because now you’re doing stage talks and podcasts. But that’s all on growth.
Amanda Floyd: Okay. I have a really weird obsession with cleanliness, and specifically, I can’t stand hair. As soon as I’m done brushing my hair, I clean the brush out. Every single strand has to be thrown away. I lint-roll my sheets every day, and our dog doesn’t get in the bed.
Luke Infinger: What if it’s somebody else’s hair, like at a restaurant?
Amanda Floyd: It’s even worse. I would probably just choose not to eat, because I’m not going to cause a big scene. For as long as I can remember, if I’m with someone and there’s a hair on them, I will very discreetly try to pick it off, because it might get on me.
Luke Infinger: What about drains? Because you have a lot of hair.
Amanda Floyd: I have a lot of hair. When I wash my hair, I have a brush in the shower and I brush it with the conditioner in, and then I clean that brush out every time I shower. My husband makes fun of me because our house is vacuumed every single day. We have a huge golden retriever, and his hair is the only hair that doesn’t bother me. But I will Swiffer the entire bathroom before I shower at night, because in my head, hair might get on my feet after I shower.
Luke Infinger: Big dogs inside is a no-go for me.
Amanda Floyd: It always was for me too, my whole life. We found Campbell about a year and a half ago, and he was meant for us. I can’t imagine our life without him.
Luke Infinger: I have a flat-coated retriever, which is like a black golden, and she sheds so much. I couldn’t imagine if she was inside.
Amanda Floyd: We get him groomed every two weeks. Golden retriever hair is so soft, and if you vacuum every day, you don’t notice it in my house.
[14:51] Meeting Dr. Ben Fishbein
Luke Infinger: Let’s talk about you meeting Ben. You were working at an office here, and it was a smaller office?
Amanda Floyd: A very small office, about $800,000 in annual production. I started working there in 2012, and I was actively looking for something very casual without a lot of responsibility.
Luke Infinger: Why?
Amanda Floyd: Casey was homeschooling. We homeschooled her for her last couple of years after we moved here, and it was her last year. I didn’t want a ton of responsibility, and I didn’t want to be working after I left the office. I managed the office in Arkansas for so long that there was always after-work stress. I wanted to go in, do my job, and go home. That lasted a very short amount of time. The doctor Ben bought the practice from got cancer, and it was a very quick transition.
Luke Infinger: Do you think that, because of your nature and personality, a backseat role isn’t realistic for you? You’re so on the ball, so organized, you have to have a schedule, and you’re a high performer. I have those thoughts too, and the reality is, with how you’re geared, it’s probably never going to happen.
Amanda Floyd: Right, I do know that. That’s why, with Ben’s new business, I’ve told him I don’t have the bandwidth to do it the way I’d want to do it. We also have another new company from this year that I’m really trying to iron out. It’s very hard for me not to be very active.
Luke Infinger: So Ben comes into this practice, and you weren’t sure you wanted a leadership role. Did Ben identify you as a leader, or were you already running the show?
Amanda Floyd: I was not running the show. We didn’t have a manager. The previous doctor did his own reviews and hiring and approved every little thing, down to every lunch that got scheduled. For every staff meeting, he was creating the notes. There was so much inefficiency, but I was one of seven people who worked there, so I didn’t care that much. Ben came in, and there was something about his energy that I really loved, because he was so motivated and so young.
Luke Infinger: How old was he?
Amanda Floyd: That was about 13 years ago, so early 30s. He’d only been out of residency about a year. He’s not that much younger than me, but in life experience he was much younger, because the ten years I’d spent working, he was in school. He was very green in the workforce. But he was very motivated, and he’s such a likable guy because he’s so humble. He asked me to manage, and at that point I wanted to go part-time. I was the full-time TC and clinical coordinator. Before he even talked to me, I told him, “I really want to stay working here, but I’d like to go part-time.” Our part-time marketing coordinator had just left, so I said I’d like to take that marketing role. I think he felt deflated, because he was getting ready to ask me to be the office manager. I was going to work two days a week. He agreed to it, because basically it was that or I was going to leave.
We were on one of those lunch deliveries in his old Nissan truck. He’d had it, I think, all through dental school and residency.
Luke Infinger: I want to see a picture of that.
Amanda Floyd: It was a four-door, maybe a Frontier. We were in his truck on the way to take lunch to a dentist in Perdido, and he said, “I know you said you wanted to go part-time, but I really need an office manager, and I think that person is you. What would you think about doing it? But before we go much further, we don’t have the budget. I can’t give you a raise.” Which, you know, was a very appealing offer. We talked about it more and went back to the office. I still have the legal pad where he scribbled notes, basically saying, “We have nothing now, but if we grow it, I will give you so much. I just need a place to start.” Obviously the rest is history. I said yes.
Luke Infinger: Do you ever think about what would have happened if you didn’t?
Amanda Floyd: I can’t imagine. I think that was what the universe had in store for me. You have pivotal moments in life where you know something is for you. Do I want to do this? No. But I felt in my gut and to my core that this was for me.
Luke Infinger: It was like a God moment.
Amanda Floyd: 100 percent. I knew that’s where God had put me in my life.
[20:42] From $4 million to $11 million
Luke Infinger: I met you guys in 2015, I think, and it took a while to start working together. I think Caleb introduced us, and Dr. Ben had heard of some of the clients we were working with, like Dr. Nielsen and a lot of the orthodontists out of Andrews. What size were you around 2015?
Amanda Floyd: We were $4 million in 2016, and from 2016 to 2017 we went from $4 million to $11 million. We opened two offices, partnered with you guys, and found some rockstar team members.
Luke Infinger: I looked back in emails once, and we started working together in March 2016.
Amanda Floyd: We opened Pace in September 2016, and we hired Sarah in the summer of 2017.
Luke Infinger: It’s funny, because I looked so rough back then. I was not taking care of myself, just working 24/7. When Ben sees the old photos, he’ll send them to me and say, “You figured out anti-aging.”
Amanda Floyd: Literally. I think we have.
Luke Infinger: Those were exciting times. I was worried all the time, but looking back, I wish I could have enjoyed it more. So in 2015 you were somewhere between $2 million and $3 million, then $4 million, then $11 million. That’s kind of insane. What do you think set you up for that type of growth?
Amanda Floyd: So many things. I think we align ourselves with the people who are meant to be in our journey going forward. Not to sound too woo-woo, but Ben and I are both very open-minded. He told me recently he’s going to be a professional pickleball player, and I believe him. If he says he’s going to do it, he’s going to do it.
Luke Infinger: He’s playing every day. I think he may have just pulled his hamstring, but if he plays every day for a year, he probably could be.
Amanda Floyd: He’s not giving it a year. It’s his seven-year plan. He wants to retire and play pickleball.
Luke Infinger: Then he’d be in the over-50 league. He’ll probably do that.
Amanda Floyd: But I know him well enough to know he’ll probably find a new passion between now and then. I’ve seen him really obsessed with other things. Remember magic?
Luke Infinger: Magic was a shorter stint. He did it at his birthday and at work, in front of almost everyone.
Amanda Floyd: He was really good at it, too.
Luke Infinger: Doctors, especially orthodontists, are typically good with their hands, and magic is sleight of hand. I’m terrible at magic, by the way.
Amanda Floyd: I’ve never even tried, and I’m not interested. If I were interested enough, I’d probably become really good at it. I’m interested in health and fitness, so I’m very good in the gym. I understand things without having to be shown, because I’m passionate about it. I think we both have that personality: we’re going to succeed really highly at something we’re interested in.
[24:36] Renovations, new offices, and Fishbein Fundamentals
Luke Infinger: When did you renovate Pensacola?
Amanda Floyd: The Pensacola renovation was complete in January 2019, so all of 2018 was a mess.
Luke Infinger: So in 2016 you did $4 million, by 2017 you were at $11 million, and in 2018 you started Fishbein Fundamentals.
Amanda Floyd: In 2018 we started Fishbein Fundamentals. We also opened two more offices in 2018, both in the same week in December. Insanity. In 2018 we were doing about $15 million, maybe $15.5 million.
Luke Infinger: Our growth kind of paralleled yours. I was thinking back on Fishbein Fundamentals, because either you or Ben asked me to come speak and I didn’t know what it was.
Amanda Floyd: We probably didn’t either.
Luke Infinger: I thought it was a small event where I’d get to speak and be a sponsor. At the time we maybe had 30 clients, and you were our only orthodontic practice. We had other healthcare clients. Because I didn’t know what the event was, one of my most exciting case studies was a nonprofit. My talk was on video ads and Facebook, and back then it was the Wild West. It’s a lot different now, but I gravitated toward it because I realized a lot of local marketers were still stuck in branding and design, and there was this whole social media wave. I thought, if I can learn direct response marketing on Facebook, it’s game over. It’s like a cheat code, and it actually proved to be that way. So I did this talk on Facebook ads and the nonprofit, and instantly four or five people came up wanting to sign up.
I had talked to Feldman before on a call, and he was very guarded, not sure if this was right for him. And he walked up and said, “We’re going to blow this up.”
Amanda Floyd: And did.
Luke Infinger: There’s only one Chris Feldman. I went to visit him, and literally every person, even at a gas station, knew him. He’s a celebrity.
Amanda Floyd: He knows everyone. He’s the biggest personality. And it’s so funny how close he and Ben are, because their personalities are so different, but they complement each other so well.
Luke Infinger: He’s so likable. I couldn’t imagine not liking him. He’s an extrovert, the life of the party, and I’m not like that at all. He took me over to his house, introduced me to his kids, and asked if we could take some family photos while we were there.
[28:11] COVID
Luke Infinger: We started to catch traction, and 2020 is when we really blew up. What was COVID like for you guys?
Amanda Floyd: It feels like a fever dream. We didn’t have the impact here that so many others had. We only had to shut down for about seven weeks. The craziest thing is we were at a Fundamentals conference, and you guys were there too.
Luke Infinger: It was literally two days before the world shut down.
Amanda Floyd: We were at a conference with people who had flown in from all over the U.S.
Luke Infinger: What’s crazy is Efros was supposed to come to that. He was my guest.
Amanda Floyd: Wow. I can’t imagine life without Greg Efros now. I remember talking to some of the attendees. Mike was down from New Jersey, and he said, “It’s crazy, Amanda. The world’s shutting down, and we all still have to get home. Then what happens?” Two or three days later, announcements were made that everyone had to shut down.
Luke Infinger: The conference ended Saturday, and Monday morning everything shut down.
Amanda Floyd: The hardest thing was that we had a large team at that point, probably 80 team members, and we were trying to figure out how to keep everyone safe and whole. Unemployment in Florida was very hard to get. So we made budget cuts, primarily marketing budget cuts, because that’s where we could find the funds, and we were able to pay our team throughout. I think that helped us open quickly afterward, because we didn’t have to figure out who was coming back.
Luke Infinger: Furlough was a thing back then. There were so many crazy things.
Amanda Floyd: We did weekly outdoor meetings with just our leadership team. We had a lot of crazy ideas and fun stuff. It’s nostalgic thinking back on it, because it was also the last few months Casey lived at home. She lived at home all through quarantine, and we would be out biking or walking for hours every day. We’d do outdoor workouts at our community center and then jog back home. A bunch of people in our neighborhood did that. She bought her first house on her own in July 2020, after quarantine ended, but it was really fun to have her home during that time.
Luke Infinger: What size were you, production-wise, around that time?
Amanda Floyd: I think we finished 2020 at maybe $20 million. It might have been 2021, but somewhere in there.
[31:00] How Amanda Floyd Consulting started
Luke Infinger: How did the transition to Amanda Floyd Consulting happen? Fishbein Fundamentals was the event, and you had tons of people coming in to visit.
Amanda Floyd: Tons of people. We would do three or four conferences a year, some in partnership with you guys. We met so many practices and teams, and they constantly wanted more. So we offered one-on-one team member training, where they could fly a few people down and we’d spend one day with them. Then they wanted more training. Organically, we started offering it to a very small number of people. We kept the list small because I was still working full-time. We’d take three at a time and do private coaching with them for three months, and when that ended, it was, “Okay, what do we do next?” It was a very organic transition. It wasn’t anything I saw myself doing full-time, but I feel like it was meant for me. I love it.
It’s funny, because in 2015 Ben and I took one of my best friends, Bree, and Casey to San Diego for a TC intensive. Dr. Ben will remember this too: on that trip, I said, “I think this is what I’m going to do.” I really loved Leanne. She was a great presence, and I thought, wow, she’s really good at this, and there aren’t enough people who are really great at this. I thought, long-term, that’s what I’m going to do. But in my head it was many years from now.
[32:54] Five years at Smile Doctors
Luke Infinger: During that time, Fishbein Orthodontics partnered with Smile Doctors. I’m sure going from private practice to an OSO was very different. At the tail end of working in what I’d call corporate, was the transition back into running a small business easier?
Amanda Floyd: I learned so much in my five years at Smile Doctors that helped me go back. Some things I knew I needed to do, and other things I knew I’m not going to do.
Luke Infinger: It’s a very different way of running a business.
Amanda Floyd: For sure. But it helped because we supported a lot of practices through Smile Doctors, not just Fishbein. It opened us up to working with people who don’t necessarily have Dr. Ben Fishbein’s mindset. I was a regional VP for Smile Doctors, which meant I was over everybody in Florida. There were so many practices, and they all had different visions, goals, and dreams, and different levels of what they were willing to put in. It opened us up to working with teams that weren’t people I had hired. What was very easy to do at Fishbein Orthodontics, we had to adjust our expectations for with others. A lot of that was because of who Ben is. People love him. He’s very generous, very humble, and very kind. We hired people who really appreciated that and would give their all, because they knew anytime they needed something, he would provide it back to them. But Smile Doctors opened us up to working with all types of doctors and teams.
[34:53] What the easiest-to-grow doctors have in common
Luke Infinger: It’s interesting you mention that, because you guys were very easy to work with, and we were delusional to some degree, especially me. I thought, this is so easy. All I have to do is turn on ads and they’re over the moon. When we started to grow, it was, “We have to get our act together,” because if we don’t know definitively that patients from what we’re doing are actually starting, beyond vanity metrics, we’re not going to retain clients. In the real world, most small businesses are messy, and you have to be super organized with great systems. To this day, some of the biggest practices we help grow, with the biggest success stories, are the easiest to work with, like Carter Thomas and Sparkman and Sanders Graf. They have some or all of the characteristics you’re describing with Ben, and they just get it. It’s innate, and some of those things you can’t teach.
Amanda Floyd: Those are our favorite partners, and the easiest, because they get it. When you’re growing, you can’t be overanalyzing every single thing that comes across your desk, every single ad or the performance of every single thing. We’ve just never been that stuck in the details.
Luke Infinger: I’d also say that while they’re hyper-analytical, they come from a positive mood and positive energy rather than a negative one. They think about growth and what’s possible, versus saying things like, “Oh, we could never do that.”
[37:09] “That would never work in our practice”
Luke Infinger: That leads me back to my research.
Amanda Floyd: Oh, I love this.
Luke Infinger: This question came up about the most expensive statement you hear from a doctor in a practice, which is, “That would never work in our practice.” On one side you have doctors saying, “I want to grow. I want to do X, Y, and Z and get to this goal.” In the middle you have this contradicting belief that will never let them get to the other side. It’s this dichotomy of, “But you said this, and I’m literally showing you.”
Amanda Floyd: Here’s a roadmap to how you get there. But you can’t skip the exits for fuel.
Luke Infinger: There are only so many routes you can take, and you have to pick one. You deal with that a lot: “This wouldn’t work for us.” People come to Fishbein Fundamentals and pick it apart. I always tell people, “Cool, you don’t want to be this model. Maybe infer how it could work instead of thinking so literally.” But that’s hard for people.
Amanda Floyd: You don’t have to build a $30 million practice, but you could build a $3 million practice. The hardest part is the people who say, “This is what I want, this is my goal,” and then aren’t willing to invest in the people who are going to help them get there. You can’t get there by yourself. And you can’t get there by nickel-and-diming employees or patients. A situation happened yesterday where I was talking to a doctor who was really upset because a patient sent an email saying she was unhappy with the results of her treatment. In that situation, 100 percent of the time, Dr. Ben would refund that patient and make the patient happy. It’s not worth fighting, because the perception in the patient’s mind is what it is, and you’re not going to change it. All fighting does is create more negative energy and potentially a negative review or a negative Facebook post, and we can’t afford that.
Luke Infinger: And time. It’s such a time saver.
Amanda Floyd: Just write it off. But people want so badly to be right.
Luke Infinger: We worked with a coach who would always say, “You don’t want to be right.”
Amanda Floyd: Dr. Ben has always said, “You can be right or you can be rich.” And I don’t care about being right that much.
Luke Infinger: Also, if you always try to be right, people will probably hate you, because that means they’re wrong.
Amanda Floyd: And nobody wants to be wrong. But “you can be right or you can be rich” doesn’t always mean financially. It’s about your energy in general. Is this worth my energy? It’s just not.
Luke Infinger: Ben is so good at that. I remember he called me once and told me a mom yelled at him for ten minutes. I said, “That sounds terrible. What did you do?” He said, “After the first 30 seconds, I just kind of blacked out. When she was done, I thanked her and walked off.”
Amanda Floyd: He’s not going to argue about it. But so many people are not willing to be wrong about anything.
[40:40] Doctors doing $20-an-hour tasks
Luke Infinger: Doctors are very smart at learning and remembering things. They went to school forever: science, anatomy. But because of that, and you and I can fall into this trap too, they want to do everything. They won’t say they want to do everything, but what people say and what they do are totally different. You’ll catch them doing $20-an-hour tasks. When I talk to doctors, I ask, “What are you doing?” They say, “My team member is really good at this, this, and this, but I have to do this because they won’t check it or they miss this detail.” Have you had that conversation with them? Have you let them watch you do it? Do you have a recorded SOP? And if they truly can’t do it, do you just keep that person in that role forever? So what do you see with the doctor who is stuck? What are they spending their time doing that they shouldn’t be?
Amanda Floyd: HR, marketing, things other people should be paid to do, making minor decisions on schedules and schedule templates. I’m shocked at how many doctors are reviewing and editing their own scheduling templates. Why?
Luke Infinger: Let me play devil’s advocate. I’m a doctor, and if it’s going to be right, I’ve got to do it. What would you tell me?
Amanda Floyd: You don’t have the right people on your team. If it’s got to be right and you have to do it, you either don’t have the right people on your team or you haven’t invested in coaching and training for them.
Luke Infinger: What if I say, “I’m a doctor, but I like to run the office”?
Amanda Floyd: That’s great. You can have a small practice that you run, and it’s probably going to be very profitable. It’s not going to be a large growth adventure, because there’s only so much you can do. Being the doctor is where you get the most return on your time. But there are people who enjoy the business, like Jesse Karmann. He’s one of the best doctors clinically I’ve ever met, and he loves the business side and being involved in it. He’s got an incredible team and a suite of great managers. I don’t think he’s ever going to be super uninvolved in the day-to-day, because he loves the thrill of the chase. He loves the numbers and the analytics.
Luke Infinger: Ben liked the business, but he knew how to engage at a high level instead of getting in the weeds. Carter loves business and has other businesses. Sparkman, too. You can like the business and understand what’s happening in it without checking everything.
Amanda Floyd: And be willing to delegate it.
Luke Infinger: I love business, and I fall into that trap all the time of jumping back into a seat, because there are some seats I enjoy. But you can’t grow that way. At a certain point you have to say, “The team has to do this, because if I’m spending all my time on this, I can’t be the CEO.” For ION to go to the next level…
Amanda Floyd: It needs Luke as the CEO.
Luke Infinger: Yes. I think it’s similar with Jesse. They might still get in their own way some, and I still do, but they understand it and try to stay big-picture.
Amanda Floyd: Jesse loves doing it, and he’s incredible. His growth story rivals ours, same as Carter’s and Sanders’. All of these doctors have really great people around them, but they enjoy the business side. Ben enjoys aspects of it too.
Luke Infinger: Ben is so good at business in certain ways. He can see things and understand them so fast.
Amanda Floyd: He’s very good. He’s the visionary with the ideas, and he can see it to the end. But then creating the structure to get it there… That’s why we partnered so well. He’s definitely the visionary.
[45:29] Getting a practice past $2 million
Luke Infinger: This isn’t to say these people are the rock stars and everybody else isn’t good. But in most practices, the thing most orthodontists are good at is moving teeth. If you’re the only one who can do that, and a TC can’t move teeth, the scheduling coordinator can’t, HR can’t, then do what only you can do. The business that can grow and keep scaling is one where you’re in your zone of genius. Ben always says the best thing an orthodontist can do for the practice is be an orthodontist.
Amanda Floyd: Put braces on and take braces off.
Luke Infinger: If you’re consulting with an office that says, “We can’t get past $2 million,” but the doctor is doing all these things, how do you get them out of that? Can you?
Amanda Floyd: It depends on their mindset. That’s why we do a series of discovery calls to see if we’re even the right fit, because we are a very growth-minded group. That’s what we excel at. If it’s the right mindset, we look for one or two rockstar people to help them on their journey. Maybe those people are already on the team and we need to identify them and give them more training. Maybe we haven’t found them yet. If you have the right mindset, and you can find a rockstar office manager, TC, and marketing person, and create roles people thrive in from start to end, you’re going to succeed. But it takes a bit of everything. It’s not just finding a rockstar TC. You also have to have great marketing, and you have to have a great person answering the phone to get those patients in the door. People want to focus on one part, and you really need all of it.
[47:34] Marketing budgets and “expensive” partners
Luke Infinger: With marketing, so many practices spend so little. This has always blown my mind. Our full fee is about $7,000 a month, but we have packages starting at $2,000 a month, and that’s without ad spend. And the stereotype of HIP or Neon is that we’re so expensive.
Amanda Floyd: Same stereotype.
Luke Infinger: There are so many things I want to say to that. The one that comes to mind is, you’re asking people to start treatment for $6,000, $7,000, $8,000. We work with some practices that have a lower-ticket model, but typically it’s $6,000 to $8,000 for full treatment. If you’re asking patients to pay you that, how is that so much money that you couldn’t invest it in your business? The thought of growing by half a million or a million or more a year while spending $2,000 a month… how does that math work? It doesn’t.
Amanda Floyd: Ben has always said you have to spend money to make money. You just do. We get the same thing. We’re what some would consider expensive, and unapologetically, our partners grow. We have a proven team that can grow your practice if you’re willing to listen and put the work in. It’s not by accident that so many of our partners are also with HIP. I think you guys are the best, and I know we’re the best as well. Miranda had a sales call a few weeks ago where someone said, “This is what we’ve been paying for consulting, and we’d like to see something around this investment.” That’s not for us. We wish them the best, but I’m not willing to compromise on what we know we deliver.
Luke Infinger: It’s like anything else. There’s nothing wrong with a Toyota or a Kia if that’s what you want, but there is a difference between that and an Audi or a Porsche. You get what you pay for.
Amanda Floyd: The tiniest thing: when I get in my car and my foot touches the brake, my door automatically closes. That’s the simplest luxury I never knew I’d care about, and now when I get in anyone else’s car, even my husband’s, I’m expecting it to close the door for me. It’s the same for us. The second someone tells us something is going on, we look at it, create a solution, and teach your team.
Luke Infinger: And you have the proof. You have endless case studies: here are the people who followed what we teach, and here’s what they did. That’s the hard part for me. With so many case studies, we should have so many more clients, but maybe that’s a conversation for another day.
[51:02] First changes in a stalled $2 to $3 million practice
Luke Infinger: Let me give you a hypothetical. You go into just about any practice in the U.S. doing somewhere between $2 million and $3 million, and they can’t get past that. What are some of the first things you change?
Amanda Floyd: The TC process, probably start to finish.
Luke Infinger: What are people doing that they shouldn’t be?
Amanda Floyd: They’re overexplaining every detail and making it so complicated. The doctor is in the room an extreme amount of time. Everything about the consult is either clunky or overdone. People, especially in the world we live in now, need simplicity, and that’s what thrives.
Luke Infinger: So you don’t think people care about all the details and the words they don’t know?
Amanda Floyd: I don’t think they do. At that point you’re creating a reason for them to go home and do more research, when if we’d made it simple to begin with, they would have started today. That’s what we do so well at Fishbein Orthodontics and what we teach. Not to keep talking about the same people, but we talk about them for a reason. They’ve had extreme growth because they listen to what works and they change. They do it.
Luke Infinger: There’s a saying in sales: the confused mind doesn’t buy.
Amanda Floyd: I wouldn’t buy either in that situation. If you make it very simple and easy, then for the “but what if this?” cases, we’ll pivot in the moment, 2 or 3 percent of the time. But 95, 96, 97 percent of the time, this is what we do, and it works.
Luke Infinger: It’s interesting, because people ask, “What if they have more questions? What if we didn’t disclose this?” And I think, they’re going to be a patient.
Amanda Floyd: You’re going to see them every eight weeks.
Luke Infinger: So answer it when they actually have the question or when it’s relevant.
Amanda Floyd: Don’t bring new questions to them. They’ve probably already researched orthodontics on the front end. We don’t need to teach them everything about how every tooth moves.
Luke Infinger: Especially now with ChatGPT. So you’d change the sales process and make it simple and easy to understand. What’s number two?
Amanda Floyd: We’d make sure the TC is a great TC. Probably 75 percent of the time, there’s a great TC in the role and that person just needs more training. In the other cases, we need to find someone else, typically within the practice. Right people, right seat is something we continually stand by. So we find someone and train them. Then the TC process, marketing systems in general, and really finding the people who can take the business to the next level, whether that’s a $3 million practice, if that’s what the doctor wants. People have this misguided perception that we only work with eight-figure practices.
Luke Infinger: Same. But most of ours are around $2 million.
Amanda Floyd: The majority of our clients are in that $2 million to $3 million range. We do have a lot of eight-figure practices because that’s what those doctors want, but not everyone wants that. It’s funny when people say, “We don’t want to be a $20 million practice.” Well, you don’t have to.
Luke Infinger: We’ve seen this too, and I’m sure you’ve seen it way more: there’s a really good TC, but they’re not TCing all the time.
Amanda Floyd: Because they’re also managing, working in the clinic, and doing all the other things.
Luke Infinger: And someone else is TCing, their close rate is really low, and you think, maybe this could work a little better.
Amanda Floyd: Or the worst is when we walk in and ask, “What’s the close rate?” and no one knows. No one even looks at it. It’s wild to me.
[54:34] Promos, discounts, and brand perception
Luke Infinger: To come back around to Facebook ads: when you’re interrupting people on social media, you need a hook. With search, people are actually looking for you. No one is looking for you on Facebook, so we have to interrupt them. A lot of times we do a promo, typically based on price, like $500 off, “as low as,” or “starting at.” We’ve run thousands of offers across thousands of practices, and typically the two that work best are $750 off and $1,000 off. They actually work almost the same, which is funny. But we hear all the time, “I don’t want to run a discount. I’m not a discount practice.” I explain that a lot of the partners we have running these offers have some of the highest fees. It’s not about cheapening your brand. It’s about the psychology of whether you want that patient to come to you or go to a dentist or another orthodontist. At the same time, I do understand not wanting to cheapen a brand. What’s your philosophy on that?
Amanda Floyd: Look, we’re going to run the $750 ad at Black Friday, and most of our clients are too. There are times of year when that’s what works, and the goal is to get someone in the door. Cheapening the brand is such a crazy way to look at it. How do you cheapen a $30 million brand like Fishbein Orthodontics?
Luke Infinger: When I come in, it’s an awesome waiting room. I did aligners there. It’s beautiful, great lighting, fun.
Amanda Floyd: Have you been in since the renovation? It’s beautiful. You’ve got to come by.
Luke Infinger: Maybe I need to get aligners again.
Amanda Floyd: You do. When we were building these offices, we didn’t have a lot of budget, so we made them pretty simple. But to your point: beautiful lighting, beautiful smiling faces.
Luke Infinger: Nice furniture, brighter colors, good music.
Amanda Floyd: A place that feels good.
Luke Infinger: What’s interesting is that when I go into the offices of people who tell me they don’t want to cheapen their brand, the building is…
Amanda Floyd: Dated.
Luke Infinger: In some cases, terrible. I’m thinking of one in New Jersey: your office looks like a prison. There are no windows, and you’re on the third floor. But you don’t want to cheapen your brand? You talk about perception and the false beliefs people have, and that’s ultimately what’s holding them back from growth. Change your mindset and you can change everything. But it’s so simple that it’s very hard for people to do.
Amanda Floyd: There’s a local boutique downtown I love to shop at. When there’s a friends-and-family sale and I see it on Instagram, I’m there. I would never think the boutique is cheapening its brand. Everything’s 20 percent off? Sign me up.
Luke Infinger: When you go to Destin or 30A, do you go to the outlets? They sell with buy two, get one, or 30, 40, 50 percent off luxury brands.
Amanda Floyd: And one of my favorite online brands, Z Supply. This sweater is Z Supply. Right before I came here, I saw they had a free cashmere scarf if you spent about $200, and I wanted the scarf, so I bought a blazer and a shirt. It doesn’t cheapen the brand. Those little promotions I see on Instagram work for me.
Luke Infinger: What’s funny is that all these doctors ask us what their discount is.
Amanda Floyd: I know.
Luke Infinger: But they tell us they don’t like promos.
[58:46] Growing without outside help
Luke Infinger: Let’s end with this. Someone isn’t able to grow, and right now it is challenging. I believe ortho is flat, even though you go on Google and some study says it’s up 3.8 percent. Yeah, but gas is up 100 percent, and wage costs are so much higher. It’s a tough time, the economy is soft, and it’s going to be soft next year. What would you tell somebody who would never work with ION, HIP, Neon, or Amanda Floyd Consulting, but just can’t grow? We’ve talked about changing your TC process, marketing budgets, promos, and price-conscious audiences. If they’re going to do it themselves, what’s next?
Amanda Floyd: If you’re a doctor, you have to find someone who is a very likable, capable self-starter, because you’re not going to grow just by wishing it into the world. Your business wouldn’t have grown to what it is without us, and ours wouldn’t have grown without you. You surround yourself with the right people, and everybody wins. If you’re trying to do it on your own, you have to find at least one or two of the right people who are willing to put in the boots-on-the-ground work to grow. We had grown before we started investing a lot in marketing, because we found a couple of great people: me, Brittany, Eliza, and Nancy, the same people we still work with now. You find people who see the vision. But if you’re doing it on your own, or worse, you’re the doctor and you’re not growing and can’t keep people, you have to do some inward work. You have to start with you. As woo-woo as it sounds, spend time on podcasts and books that will grow you as a person and change the limiting mindset that’s causing you not to grow.
Luke Infinger: That’s the biggest thing for a doctor who may never work with us: work on personal development. It’s like the oxygen mask on a plane. Put your mask on first, because if you don’t, you can’t help anyone. Work on you, develop your mindset and your belief, and then you can attract other people and help them with that.
Amanda Floyd: 100 percent. I have a really strict morning routine, and I’m sure a lot of high achievers do. On days when I decide I’m not going to get up and do my Bible study, my devotional, my 10,000 steps, my workout, my vibration plate, journaling, and listening to a book, I don’t have as smooth a morning. I set my routine up to create an easy day going forward. When I skip it, by 3:00 PM I’m only at 3,000 steps and I’m annoyed about it. But if I use that first hour of the day, even if it means giving up a little sleep, I’m setting myself up for success.
Luke Infinger: You can’t change the winning strategy. I did this with my health. I thought, I’ve nailed my diet for two or three years, I’m working out every day, I’m cold plunging, I’m in the red light. Maybe I didn’t have to do all of those things, but the foundational things, yes: move your body, blood flow, sunlight. When you decide you’re not going to do that anymore, you show up differently. So don’t change what’s helping you win your day.
[1:02:46] Where to find Amanda
Luke Infinger: If somebody wants to learn more, where should they go?
Amanda Floyd: amandafloydconsulting.com. Reach out to Miranda at Miranda@fishbeingroup.com. Or find me on Instagram. I’m very active on Instagram. It’s funny, I keep a separate personal account, and I don’t even have to log in to our business account.
Luke Infinger: I had to ask Zach the other day how to log in to HIP’s.
Amanda Floyd: That’s because we’re good delegators. We have people who are great at it. Miranda is always on our business page, but so many of our clients find me through my personal Instagram, because I’ll just chat with people there. So amandafloydconsulting.com, or find me on Instagram.
Luke Infinger: Cool. Thanks for coming on.
Amanda Floyd: Of course. I’m always happy to be here.
Want this kind of growth plan for your practice?
HIP Creative builds the marketing, phone, and patient acquisition systems behind some of the fastest-growing orthodontic practices in the country.


